Important Auto Insurance Question?

A non-American girl, arrives in the USA to start her studies. She has a drivers license she received from her home country. There is this "law" saying that if a foreing person already has a driver's license he/she can transfer it into an american drivers license without taking the road test. So she did just that.??She went to an auto insurance agency. The person there simply asked her whether she has been driving for 4 years, without specifying that she had to be driving in the USA for 4 years. She answered positively even though she hadnt been driving in the USA for 4 years. Now she is insured with that company.??I'm 22 from the same country just got my drivers license in the USA without "transfering" the one i got from my home country. I called the same company for a quote, telling them that i have been driving since i was 18 in my home country (hoping i wasnt considered as a new driver) and what they told me was that "we cant insure you because you dont have any driving record in
the US". ??So what i want to know is: How does an insurance company know whether a foreign new driver is really a new driver or not???Someone told me that if that person was never licensed in the US then the insurance company will have to take your word for it. Is that true??

I don't know to which state you are referring, but I'm a licensed insurance broker in New York. Generally, if you can demonstrate previous driving history – from anywhere – you should not be considered a "new" driver. In New York you have to show three years driving history to no longer be considered "inexperienced". They don't simply have to take your word for it; you have to prove it. While your original license (if you still have it) should show a issue date which would demonstrate driving experience, the most helpful thing that you could do for yourself would be to secure a copy of your driving history/record/abstract from your home country which would show not only the original issue date of your driver's license but also your driving history. Good luck!